Buy This Entire Record For
Norris v. Bottling Group, LLC
United States District Court, Fifth Circuit
October 10, 2013
EDITH NORRIS, Plaintiff,
BOTTLING GROUP, LLC, FORMERLY DOING BUSINESS AS PEPSI COLA GENERAL BOTTLERS, INC., AND DIA PHILLIPS, INDIVIDUALLY, Defendants. and WAL-MART ASSOCIATES AND NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY OF PITTSBURGH, PA, Intervenors,
SHARION AYCOCK, District Jude.
This cause comes before the Court on Defendants' Motion to Dismiss  for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Plaintiff filed her original Complaint  with the Court on April 22, 2013. Thereafter, Plaintiff filed her first Amended Complaint  substituting Dia Phillips for the previously named John Doe defendant. Plaintiff's Amended Complaint alleged that both she and Phillips were residents of Shelby County, Tennessee. On that basis, Defendants moved the Court to dismiss Plaintiff's Amended Complaint arguing that complete diversity did not exist among the parties, and thus the Court lacked subject matter jurisdiction.
Prior to the Court's ruling on Defendants' motion, Plaintiff filed a Second Motion for Leave to Amend  seeking to correct the pleading of Plaintiff's residency. Plaintiff argued that she is and always has been a resident of Mississippi and that simple error had led to her earlier pleading that she was a resident of Tennessee. Defendants did not oppose Plaintiff's motion and conceded in their response that, based upon the allegations contained therein, the parties are completely diverse. The Court granted the motion, and Plaintiff filed her Second Amended Complaint  on September 17, 2013 alleging that each of the ...