Searching over 5,500,000 cases.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.


FEBRUARY 13, 1985




A Rankin County jury convicted Cheryl A. Hester of the capital murder of Harley Winn, who was found stabbed to death in the woods near a trailer park in Pearl, Mississippi. The jury sentenced Hester to life imprisonment. Of the several points she raises on appeal, we address only the issue of the validity of the search warrant and whether the evidence presented by the state was legally sufficient to support a verdict of guilty. The investigation leading to Hester's arrest will first be reviewed to give an overview; then the evidence and testimony adduced at trial will be examined at length.

About 6:45 p.m., on June 4, 1982, members of the Pearl police department were called to investigate a dead body found in the woods in an unused part of a trailer park off Highway 80 in Pearl. The victim, an elderly man, was identified from cards in his wallet as Harley Winn. He died of multiple stab wounds to the neck and torso. The time of death was fixed at between 4:00 p.m. and 6:00 p.m. Winn's wallet contained no money and his pants pockets had been turned inside out with change scattered about the body. A trail of blood stretched between the road and the body and the leaves along this trail had been disturbed.

 Investigation of Winn's recent whereabouts led police to Ernie's bar on West Capitol Street, Jackson. A waitress recalled seeing Winn in the company of a woman who had recently given blood. At the Alpha Plasma Center police were given the defendant's name based on the description by the waitress at Ernie's. Another waitress, Linda Pigg, told police she had seen Winn leave the bar with a woman about 4:00 p.m. the day of the murder. Ms. Pigg saw the same woman return alone to the bar about 6:00 p.m. in a disheveled condition and in a hurry to get her friends to leave with her.

 Police obtained a warrant on July 7, 1982, to search the mobile home occupied by Hester and her boy friend,

 Lavon Murray, for a knife or similar weapon thought to be the murder weapon. Hester was arrested and a long blade folding knife was seized from the basket in the living room. A crime lab analysis of the knife showed only traces of blood, too minute to even type as human. A second search warrant was issued on July 11, 1982, to seize a five-gallon pail of water near the knife, but no trace of blood could be located in the water.


 Hester challenges the admissibility of the knife on the basis that the justice court judge was not presented with sufficient facts to support a finding of probable cause to issue the search warrant. Justice Court Judge Blaine was given a sworn affidavit by investigating officer Manning and Mississippi Highway Patrol investigator Virgil Luke, which reads:

 Harley M. Winn, white, male age 61 was found murdered at Hillard Trailer Park in the City of Pearl, Rankin County. The cause of death was established as multiple stab wounds. The body was found June 4, 1982 at 6:45 PM.

 On June 4, 1982 a Vonda Odom, employed at Ernie's Bar on Capitol Street in Jackson, Ms. did witness Harley M. Winn leaving the bar with a white female, later known to be Cheryl A. Hester at about 4:00 P.M.

 The reason Ms. Odom knew that it was 4:00 PM when the subjects left the bar, was because she gets off work at 4:00 P.M. When the subject Cheryl A. Hester returned to the bar at approximately 6:00 Pm. Linda Smith noticed that Cheryl A. Hester came in alone. Also the manager, Bob Wilson of Ernie's Bar, alos (sic) witnessed Cheryl returning at 6 PM.

 Mr. Winn and Ms. Hester had left the bar in a car being driven by Ms. Hester.

 The Coroner, MJimmy Roberts (sic) and Dr. Galvez of University Medical Center affixed the time of death as between 4 and 6:00 P.M.

 Investigators Manning and Luke also gave sworn oral testimony of the results of Manning's investigation.

 Manning was the only officer with direct knowledge of the witnesses' testimony. Luke related under oath the facts that Manning had developed and let Manning fill in the details. The written affidavit was only a summary of what the officers told Judge Blaine.

 Manning said that the waitress Pigg saw Hester return alone to Ernie's about 6:00 p.m., looking as if she had been in a scuffle with her hair sticking up and with leaves and grass in her hair. Pigg told Manning that Hester told her friends," Let's go, we've got to get out of here. "Manning told the judge that Winn had been seen earlier flashing a wad of money around in Ernie's. Manning said that, earlier, waitress Odom saw Winn apply ice to Hester's arm to stop bleeding where she had given blood at a blood bank. Manning told the judge that Winn had been found with both front pockets pulled out, where he usually carried his money.

 Investigator Luke added that Hester and Murray had befriended Winn to the point where Winn was spending his money on them. When this reached an extreme, Winn dropped them and avoided them for two weeks. The day before the murder, the three began to associate together again.

 Hester focuses upon three discrepancies which developed at the suppression hearing to conclude that probable cause was not shown. First, Manning admitted that none of his witnesses saw Winn drive away from Ernie's in Hester's car, contrary to the affidavit. Second, Luke said that the judge was shown a photograph of Winn missing one shoe and sock, when in fact the photograph shows both Winn's shoes and socks were on. Third, while Manning and Luke positively recalled telling Judge Blaine that Hester returned looking like she had been in a fight and had leaves in her hair, Judge Blaine could only recall being told she was" ruffled up a little ".

 The written affidavit, standing alone, did not, in the trial judge's, or our own, opinion establish probable cause to issue the search warrant. Hester concedes, as she must, that affidavits insufficient on their face, may be supplemented by sworn oral testimony to show sufficient facts to establish probable cause. Wilborn v. State, 394 So.2d 1355, 1357 (Miss. 1981); Read v. State, 430 So.2d 832, 834-35 (Miss. 1983); Lee v. State, 435 So.2d 674, 677 (Miss. 1983). Hester contends that Judge Blaine relied upon the disproven facts ...

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.