BEFORE ROY NOBLE LEE, DAN LEE AND PRATHER
PRATHER, JUSTICE, FOR THE COURT:
This is an appeal from a criminal conviction in the Circuit Court of Hinds County, the Honorable William F. Coleman presiding. Herman Kelly was indicted for murder of Walter Ray Summers, but found guilty of manslaughter and sentenced to 15 years at the Mississippi Department of Corrections. Kelly appeals, assigning as error:
(1) That the trial court erred in failing to require the State to elect between the charges of murder and manslaughter;
(2) The trial court erred in overruling appellant's motion for a mistrial after the District Attorney entered the case without having attended the voir dire of the jury;
(3) The trial court erred in granting a manslaughter instruction for the State which omitted material elements of the crime;
(4) The trial court erred in refusing a self-defense instruction offered by the defense;
(5) The trial court erred in admitting photographs of the victim;
(6) The trial court erred in limiting cross-examination of a prosecution witness;
(7) The trial court erred in allowing the prosecution to withhold an exculpatory statement by the defendant from its case in chief; and
(8) The verdict was against the overwhelming weight of the evidence. I.
Around midnight of August 21, 1981, appellant Herman Kelly entered BB's Lounge in Terry, Mississippi and shot Walter Ray" Bobo "Summers. Summers received a bullet wound to the upper right side of his chest severing an artery and bled to death on the floor of the bar.
Appellant Kelly was 52 years old at the time of the shooting and had lived in Terry, Mississippi for 18 years. During the 2 1/2 years preceding the crime, Kelly was employed as a handyman and caretaker by Ben Johnson, a Hinds County Real Estate businessman. Kelly occasionally does odd jobs and yard work for other Terry residents. His reputation in the Terry community for truthfulness and peacefulness is good.
On August 21, 1981, appellant Kelly left the Johnson place in Mr. Johnson's truck around 4:00 o'clock p. m. Kelly had loaded up some chickens and drove around the outskirts of Terry selling them for Mr. Johnson. After Kelly sold all of the chickens, he returned to his home and washed off Mr. Johnson's truck. Kelly left his house around 9:30 or 10:00 o'clock p. m. and went to visit James Greene, Deputy Sheriff with the Hinds County Penal Farm, for about half an hour. Kelly then went to a grocery store, bought a beer and some cigarettes and, at approximately 11:00 p. m., proceeded to BB's Place.
Kelly entered BB's with a pistol tucked in his pants. Seven or eight months earlier Kelly had traded a shotgun and a hog to Deputy Greene in return for the pistol. According to Kelly, he was carrying the pistol on the night of August 21, 1981 in order to protect the $1200 radio which Mr. Johnson
Kelly testified that upon entering BB's Lounge, Summers cursed him and told him not to come inside. According to Kelly, Summers said" I'm gonna kill you "and reached under his shirt; Kelly then pulled out his pistol and shot him. Kelly testified that, after the shooting, he grabbed Summers and offered to take him to a doctor. When Summers refused, Kelly stated that he placed him in a chair and left BB's Place to get help.
Walter Ray" Bobo "Summers had arrived at BB's Place around 11:00 o'clock with Ida Rae McCaskill, his first cousin. At the time of the shooting, McCaskill was facing the jukebox with her back to the door. She had a hearing problem; the music was loud and she heard nothing until the door slammed. At that point she turned around and saw appellant Kelly shoot Summers who was standing at the corner of the pool table.
Curtis Bankston was managing BB's Place on the night of August 21, 1981, but was outside the building when he heard a shot and rushed back inside the lounge. Appellant Kelly was standing in the doorway with a pistol in his hand and said to Bankston," the pistol must have went off. I didn't intend to kill him ".
Approximately 10 minutes after the shooting, appellant Kelly located Lee Roland, the Night Marshall for Terry, Mississippi. Kelly told Roland that he had killed a man and wanted to give himself up. Appellant Kelly told Officer Roland that Walter Summers had threatened to kill him if he entered the bar. Additionally, Kelly told Roland that he thought that his gun was uncocked when it went off. When Roland asked for the gun, Kelly gave it to Officer Roland.
WHETHER THE TRIAL COURT ERRED IN FAILING TO REQUIRE THE STATE TO ELECT BETWEEN THE CHARGES OF MURDER AND MANSLAUGHTER.
Appellant challenges the failure of the trial court to require the State to elect between the charges of murder and manslaughter on two grounds. Appellant first argues that this invited the jury to compromise their verdict. This argument is not supported by any legal authority and therefore it need not be addressed on appeal. Pate v. State, 419 So.2d 1324 (Miss. 1982); Dozier v. ...